Poor performance by blacks: Is it due to racism or leftism?

Walter E. Williams highlights statistics on schooling, crime, fatherlessness

Walter Williams

By Walter Williams
Published November 17, 2020 at 7:10pm


You present to a physician with severe abdominal pain. He examines you and concludes that your ingrown toenails are the cause of your abdominal distress. He prescribes that you soak your feet in warm water, but that does not bring relief to your abdominal pain. Then he suggests that you apply antibiotics to your feet. Still no relief. Then the physician suggests that you wear sandals instead of shoes. Still no relief. The point of this story is that your toenails can be treated until the cows come home, but if there is improper diagnosis, then you are still going to have your abdominal pain.

The former superintendent of Atlanta Public Schools, Meria Carstarphen, last year said, “White students are nearly 4.5 grade levels ahead of their black peers within Atlanta Public Schools.” In San Francisco, 70% of white students are proficient in math; for black students, it is 12% – a gap of 58%. In Washington, D.C., 83% of white students scored proficient in reading, as did only 23% of black students – a gap of 60%. In Philadelphia, 47% of black students scored below basic in math and 42% scored below basic in reading. In Baltimore, 59% of black students scored below basic in math and 49% in reading. In Detroit, 73% of black students scored below basic in math and 56% in reading. 

“Below basic” is the score a student receives when he is unable to demonstrate even partial mastery of knowledge and grade-level skills. How much can racism explain this? To do well in school, someone must make a kid do his homework, get a good night’s rest, have breakfast and mind the teacher. If these basic family functions are not performed, it makes little difference how much money is put into education; the result will be disappointing.

Advertisement – story continues below

In 2019, the racial breakdown of high school seniors who took the ACT college entrance exam and met its readiness benchmarks was 62% of Asians, 47% of whites, 23% of Hispanics and 11% of blacks. That helps explain a 2016 study by Georgetown University’s Center on Education and the Workforce “African Americans: College Majors and Earnings.” It found that black college students were highly concentrated in lower-paying and less academically demanding majors like administrative services and social work. They are much less likely than other students to major in science, technology, engineering and math, even though blacks in these fields earned as much as 50% more than blacks who earned a bachelor’s degree in art or psychology and social work. 

James D. Agresti, the president and co-founder of Just Facts has just published an article titled “Social Ills That Plague African Americans Coincide with Leftism, Not Racism.” Agresti writes: “Among all of the afflictions that disproportionately impact people of color, violence may be the worst. In 2018, blacks comprised 13% of the U.S. population but roughly 53% of the 16,000 murder victims.” The clearance rate for murders, where a suspect was identified and charged, declined from 92% in 1960 to 62% in 2018. For example, in Chicago, the clearance rate fell from 96% in 1964 to 45% in 2018. In Baltimore, the 2019 clearance rate was 32%. In 2015, when Baltimore experienced the highest per-capita murder rate in its history, the average homicide suspect had been previously arrested more than nine times. When crimes remain unsolved, it gives criminals free range, and black people are their primary victims. By the way, most law enforcement occurs at the local level. The governments at these local levels are typically dominated by Democrats.

TRENDING: Rioter who punched out Trump supporter in viral video is registered child sex offender

According to statistics about fatherless homes, 90% of homeless and runaway children are from fatherless homes; 71% of pregnant teenagers lack a father figure; 63% of youth suicides are from fatherless homes; 71% of high school dropouts come from fatherless homes; and 70% of juveniles in state-operated institutions have no father. Furthermore, fatherless boys and girls are twice as likely to drop out of high school and twice as likely to end up in jail. Dr. Thomas Sowell has argued, “The black family, which had survived centuries of slavery and discrimination, began rapidly disintegrating in the liberal welfare state that subsidized unwed pregnancy and changed welfare from an emergency rescue to a way of life.”

The bottom line is that while every vestige of racial discrimination has not been eliminated, today’s discrimination cannot go very far in explaining the problems faced by a large segment of the black community.

Poor performance by blacks: Is it due to racism or leftism?

Unending public health crises will keep authoritarians busy forever

By Eric Utter

Indiana University Health recently announced that it will bravely stand against racism, injustice, and inaction.”  (Somebody has to!  And a university, at that!  The rest of us are all for inaction, injustice, and racism!)  I.U.’s health system has vowed to view and fight racism as a “public health crisis.”  It will join two other Indianapolis hospital networks in essentially treating racism as if it were a disease.  The three hospitals issued a joint statement claiming that systemic racism in the health care industry can lead to less desirable outcomes among minority communities.  Ergo, the institutions vow to be “focused on improving access to care and eliminating racial biases that contribute to poor health outcomes.” 

Apart from the fact that the only systemic racism in America today is that universally and incessantly directed at white people and their supposed (and assumedly “systemic”) “privilege,” treating racism of any form as a health crisis is just another way of allowing government to dictate every aspect of our lives.  “Health experts” and progressives are labeling more and more things as “public health crises” every day.  If the COVID-19 pandemic ever goes away, the “systemic racism public health crisis” can seamlessly take its place.  Rampant homelessness is waiting in the wings, too, as are depression, alcoholism, opioid abuse, and heart disease.  Add to those the clear public health threats of Lyme Disease, incontinence, the heartbreak of psoriasis, Irritable Bowel Syndrome and Dupuytren’s Contracture, and the New Totalitarians will have an endless number of excuses for an endless number of new laws, requirements, and mandates.  In light of these terrible “public health crises,” lockdowns and mail-in voting will become as inescapable and eternal as death and taxes. 

Welcome to the Grand Illusion.  We’ve all been duped.  COVID-1984, though very real, was also an excuse, a prelude to the nearly nationwide lockdowns.  The intense and unrelenting campaign of terror conducted by the government and media surrounding the coronavirus soon morphed into the equally intense and unrelenting drive to get all of us to vote by mail.  This, in turn, allowed an election to be stolen. 

Sickeningly, the “elites” in positions of influence and power knew how this was going to play out all along.  Because they planned it.  If you think they truly, deeply care about the health of non-white people — or that of the deplorable chumps in flyover country —  you are sadly mistaken.  The new serfdom awaits us all.

“Public health crisis”? Systemic corruption and cheating by the Deep State to steal an election clearly constitute a “public health crisis” of the highest order. And it is one from which the republic is unlikely to recover.